It is something different than just acute introversion that sticks this chasm in my chest, I think. I can’t put my finger on what it is, which is intensely frustrating for me, but there is something about people here lately that has worn me down farther than late-night listen-throughs of Bon Iver can cure.
Humans sadden me. It is a terrible task we are put with on this earth: toil to eat, find God, deal with each other. Some days, it seems as though we are bad at all three simultaneously, but as I write this, that’s not what saddens me, even though I thought it might have been. What you are about to read is me thinking out loud (in type), attempting to unravel something of the sadness.
I suppose I shall construct something of an argument, even though I don’t know what that argument will be. The first step, I think, is to acknowledge that there is something quite different about humans than the rest of sentient Creation. I could, of course, use God-talk to describe this difference, but such a notion is standoffish and “not-good-enough” for my dissenters, so I will use something like Reason instead (which I also believe to be God-talk, but that is a topic for another day).
I believe it was John Locke who said that a human is a “thinking thing,” with thought being something quite inseparable from consciousness (if you can say “I think,” you supposedly have something like consciousness). I find this definition to be quite lacking, though, because there are a great number of thinking creatures which are not at all human. Octopuses (Octopi? This is such an awkward word.) are, apparently, creatures of incredibly complex intelligence, capable of doing things that are generally associated with Human intelligence, like learning by observation without being told. Elephants can learn to work together to accomplish basic tasks undoable by one elephant alone. Dolphins form alliances and brotherhoods and possess the same structures in the brain that humans have that allow for cognition and the processing of emotion. Chimps can identify objects and interpret pictures, communicating it with ASL. Humans are not alone as “thinking things.”
Yet the majority of us still assert that there is something that sets us apart from even the most intelligent thinking creatures (the smartest of which may be more intelligent than the dumbest of Humans… but again. A topic for another day). It could be that we are capable of undergoing Philosophical projects – we can sit and engage with some issue entirely in our minds. It could be that we are capable of introspection and self-analysis, that we can dissociate the concept of “self” and see it from a somewhat objective point of view. It could be that we possess the ability to ponder what it is that makes us human.
Again, the things presented here can be subject to speculation. For instance, I cannot say with absolute certainty that any other person I see around me is capable of mental projects. I assume that they have brains, for I have a brain, and I have read in some books and whatnot that it is impossible for humans to function without brains, but I have no way of KNOWING. Likewise, I assume that they can think and do “mind things” because I assume that they have brains and that they function like mine does. But at its core, the Problem of Other Minds (as the Philosophy of Mind likes to shout in your face) is a troubling one that cannot be conquered by reasoning or really anything but speculation. Perhaps I’ll write another day on why I am not troubled by this, because I can feel this train rapidly derailing.
What I have discovered about what makes us Humans (again, without employing traditional God-talk) is that we are the most imperfect of creatures on the planet. We do not have the luxury that crabs do of fulfilling our crab-tasks of scuttling about and molting our shells and eating plankton and whatnot and calling that a “good life.” We do not have the simplicity that bees do of our purpose being to pollinate flowers and make honey and terrify children playing in their back yards. Instead, we are animals cursed with the nagging question “why am I here?”, the plague of doubt, and this unceasing capability of letting each other down constantly.
But that is what makes us beautiful.
This not the sadness that I feel, for I am of the persuasion that from the greatest capacity for failure comes the greatest possibility for joy. We have fallen and will continue to fall so far that the prospect of Grace, a lighthouse shining a lamp from the shore, appears to us at once beautiful and terrifying and stark.
No, the sadness that I feel is that we do all we can to eliminate it.
Put on your happy smile, kid; don’t let them see you cry. We sell paste to paint our faces while we shout “you’re perfect just the way you are.” We hide the scars that hurt the most in their getting and mock the flaws in others we’re most ashamed of in ourselves. We have to have the perfect family and the perfect job and we have to make sure that people know whatever happened “back then” doesn’t bother us anymore, because that may show lack of Faith, when in reality it gnaws at your stomach each time you breathe, nauseates at the thought of it, and gives you that bit of unsettling doubt that says “if I can’t deal with this, what makes me worthy of somebody else dealing with it as well?”
I am quick to call the man with a cardboard sign a liar looking for booze, and I quickly forget that I am the more egregious liar for pretending it doesn’t bother me.
I’ll tell you what the sadness is: we are tin soldiers on the brink of being created anew with flesh and feeling and a connection to the One that creates beautiful things, if only we would realize that it is tin we are constructed of. Instead, we gild the rusty metal and spray the flesh-smelling perfume and act as though our tin-ness is something to be ashamed of. Like we will appear as nothing but tin fools to the myriad of tin fools around us.
Like if we don’t appear to have our acts together, we will appear stupid to the rest of us who don’t have our acts together.
The first step (so they say) is admission, and it is the one that we skip the most. Admission of humanity is a terrifying thing – it’s stripping naked and taking off the makeup and saying “look at me and see how imperfect I am. Why would I expect perfection from you?” It is painful, because you can feel the wandering eyes probing the gaping wounds left by abusive husbands and hallway bullies and needle-punctured track marks, and you realize that once the Phantom’s mask has been lifted, that porcelain outside cannot be seen again. It feels like loss, but I promise you it is gain. For how should something that insists it is not broken ever be fixed?
We are a broken species, capable of the vilest of evils, but for some reason are the recipients of the most marvelous Grace. Yes, I admit that I am perhaps unduly critical of humanity, but it isn’t a thing of hate, it is one of a recognition of this potential that so few seem willing to push for.
You want to know the difference between humans and the rest of our “thinking kin” on earth, which not even the most current branches of theory of Evolution can account for? It’s Love. I’m not talking about butterflies or sex or whatever it is Freud and Tumblr and MTV have made love out to be, I’m talking about the act of Love. Where you say, “I’m going to show you exactly who I am and trust you with it. It’s going to be awkward and it’s going to hurt and you are more than capable of rejecting it, but that is what makes it worth it.” Do we understand what loving our neighbor means? It is in no way merely “doing nice things for them.” It IS, however, saying, “I’m not perfect, so I won’t pretend to be. And I won’t expect you to be, either.”
